Blueberry Thumbprint Cookies

Blueberry Thumbprint Cookies | Soft, chewy, gooey, blueberry bliss all wrapped up into one petite cookie. Shall I even mention healthy? If you can put dessert and healthy in the same category, but we will leave that debate for another conversation and just roll with it. But seriously, these turned out better than I imagined.

Let’s be honest, I’ve not had great success in the cookie category before. Like epic fail, time and time again. Some are edible, just not pretty. Others are neither. So I must tell you that I am pretty proud once I finally got these to turn out. To be completely honest, the thumbprint was a last ditch effort after I threw my arms up when the shape I was originally going for kept failing. I gave up, rolled the dough into balls, pushed the center in and filled it with the gooey blueberry filling popped it in the oven and 20 minutes later when the timer went off, I looked in the oven and it felt like my jaw could have hit the ground. I believe I yelled B-E-A-U-T-I-F-U-L out loud ->embarrassing<- !

They were prefect, tears of joy now welling in my eyes (okay that part really didn’t happen, although being 39 weeks pregnant and overly hormonal it sure could have). These beautiful blueberry thumbprint cookies sat before my eyes and turned out to be one of my new found favorite cookie recipes. Seriously, it is a good thing I finally got fed up with the triangular shape / hand pie thing I was originally shooting for because you would have  never gotten this recipe on the blog.

Blueberry Thumbprint Cookies |

Let alone being beautiful, did I mention how chewy and gooey these things are? Drool! For real guys, these are delicious and that blueberry filling, well besides for spooning it straight into your mouth and putting it in the center of these cookies there are numerous other things you could do with it. Try topping it on this porridge or how about on pudding? You could even get a little frisky and plop some on a burger.

These were so delicious that the little hands in our house obviously had a hard time waiting for me to snap some pictures. The children and the hubby are officially over me being a food blogger. To them, pictures are not necessary, they would rather just eat every last bite. A little sampling won’t hurt, right? Turns out these little hands loved the blueberry filling more than the cookie. I later found the plate of cookies I sat on the table licked clean of blueberry filling, cookies left intact. Unfortunately, I found evidence on the culprit’s face. But seriously, how could you discipline that? I certainly couldn’t blame her.

Blueberry Thumbprint Cookies |

Now go turn your oven on and get bakin’!

Blueberry Thumbprint Cookies
  1. In a medium sized sauce pan, add the blueberries, syrup, water, lemon juice, nutmeg and cinnamon. Heat over medium heat.
  2. Bring filling to a boil, while stirring. Continue to stir frequently, while "mashing" the filling with a wooded spoon.
  3. Once the liquid has reduced, turn heat down and add starch. Stir continuously until thickned. Remove from heat and set aside for filling the cookies. Can add additional ½ cup blueberries if desired.
  4. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  5. In a large mixing bowl, stir together the almond flour, arrowroot, and salt.
  6. Add in the vanilla extract, maple syrup, and melted coconut oil. Stir until all ingredients are combined and you have a ball of cookie dough. **You can use your hands for this as well.
  7. Prepare a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.
  8. Take a small ball of dough and roll until about the size of a ping-pong ball.
  9. Place on cookie sheet and press thumb into center making a well.
  10. Add about a teaspoon (give or take) of filling to the center of the cookies.
  11. Repeat until all dough has been used.
  12. Place in the oven and bake cookies for 20 minutes.
  13. Remove from oven and place on a cooling rack.
  14. **Any remaining filling can be refrigerated or frozen and saved for future use.



Auden Faith Schirm Has Arrived

“For you are fearfully and wonderfully made.” She’s here! Auden Faith made her grand appearance into the world on Tuesday July 15th at 12:01 pm, weighing in at 6 pounds 1 ounce and 21 inches long she looks just like her daddy and is everything we could have ever dreamed! After two difficult births with our… 

Read More »


The Essentials For Replenishing Lost Electrolytes

It’s the heat of the summer, mid July, temperatures are soaring everywhere, sports camps are in full swing, marathons are happening, and sweat is flying. A common pick-me-up during these summer activities are sports drinks. The isles of grocery stores are littered with neon colored, sugar-laden beverages promising to provide all of the nutrients needed to… 

Read More »


Buttery Sweet Corn, Tomato and Feta Salad

It’s true, we are officially a redneck family. My husband informed me that we have pumpkins growing in our yard where he threw out the rotting ones from last fall. Here’s the visual on our yard, we seriously have no grass, just sand, weeds and more sand. You wouldn’t guess we live in the heartland,… 

Read More »


Sunflower Crunch Chopped Salad Remix

Have you seen the latest salad hit in the grocery store isles? Chopped salads. It really is quite an amazing thing, especially for someone who doesn’t like to gnaw on huge hunks of dark leafy greens. The concept of simply chopping up those leaves and other veggies into very small pieces is genius in helping… 

Read More »


Feeding Our Children’s Minds

I’m running low on steam. This baby has been roasting for 39 weeks and counting which is amazing for me, (more on this to come) and I have hit a wall. Sluggish, tired, waddling, and did I mention tired. Hence why the wellness Wednesday posts may slow down for a few weeks. Hopefully soon you… 

Read More »


Shrimp BLT Salad

I hope everyone had a lovely fourth of July weekend! It was the most beautiful weather here, which is pretty incredible this time of the year in the midwest. Usually perspiration starts beading up on your face the instant you walk outside in the humidity but luckily we had a few days off from that…. 

Read More »


Sweet and Spicy Grilled Chicken

Earlier this week I had mentioned that our local town was holding it’s annual celebration. Now, while nothing spectacular when you live in a town of 5,000, the kids still find enjoyment in riding the decades old faux train cars (pulled by a golf cart) and going to the local parade filled with local businesses,… 

Read More »


10 Tips for a Guilt Free Holiday

Just like any other American Holiday, most of the celebrations for the fourth of July revolve around food. This could become a problem as many of us would like to eat healthy or continually work on becoming healthier, but the fear of sugar and fat binges can easily seep in. A question I get asked… 

Read More »


Strawberry Shortcake

Can you believe it…it is fourth of July week already! Where is summer going? This week I promise to bring you some very popular yet healthy fourth of July recipes. Festive right? Usually I remember these things the week after a Holiday. So I’m stating it here, my goal, healthy, summery, yummy, recipes.  I’m coming… 

Read More »


Garlic Buttered Shrimp

MMMM…garlicky, buttery, divine shrimp. Seriously it doesn’t get much better than this. I could have woofed down that entire platter of shrimp in one sitting. If only you could do a scratch and sniff with these blog things. Okay, that may be slightly strange but the smell of shrimp simmering in a garlic butter sauce… 

Read More »